extra credit book cover
ARC, Book Reviews, College, Contemporary, New Adult, Provided for Review, Reverse Harem, Romance, Slow Burn, Uncategorized

Review | Extra Credit by Autumn Reed

disclosure: this post may contain affiliate links. please visit my disclosure policy for more details.
review banner


This book is in the same world as the Lonely Souls series, but while we do see Thea and her men again, this story is about Violet and her men. You don’t necessarily have to read Thea’s series to read this book, but it’s definitely helpful to completely understand the full context and characters.

Also, as a note…the Lonely Souls series is inspired by The Wizard of Oz and Extra Credit is inspired by Rapunzel/Tangled. No, these are not retellings, but you can see the inspiration woven within the stories. As The Wizard of Oz and Tangled are two of my absolute favorite movies, I was even more thrilled with these stories.

The Heroine

Violet starts out as super meek and…well…a total pushover. I liked her, but at the same time, she was kind of one of those characters I couldn’t help but get frustrated with and think, jeez, just grow a backbone already. I mean, don’t get me wrong, I understand totally what it’s like to want to make your parents/family happy…but this was over the top. Thankfully, she does grow that backbone and she becomes MUCH more likable as the story progresses. While obviously a romance, this is truly a coming-of-age novel with what I believe to be an important narrative. Violet has been through so much and she’s spent her entire life trying to make her mother happy. Her mom is a perfect example of a manipulator and emotional blackmailer and it was so frustrating to see her in action. Thankfully, Violet ultimately comes into her own and learns to stand up for herself, but I’ll be honest–the journey there is kind of rough.

The Heroes

Jude, Lincoln, and Tobias are all so different, yet they complement each other incredibly well. The premise of Violet tutoring BioGuy was so sweet and I enjoyed their conversations. The slow burn buildup was the kind of swoony, butterflies-in-the-stomach interaction that I live for in a romance. Each guy has something different to bring to the table and they each have a different relationship with Violet that’s sweet and fun. Jude is more serious while Lincoln is playful and Tobias is kind of the friend-to-lover. Also, I know the author didn’t necessarily base him on the Rapunzel characters, but Lincoln reminded me so much of Flynn Rider and I adored it. Each guy had different qualities that made him perfect for Violet, but my personal favorite was definitely Lincoln 🙂

Bullet Points

  • Violet’s progression in this book was incredibly inspiring. I genuinely loved her character, despite being completely different from Thea (see my review for Thea’s story beginning here).
  • When I first became aware of who Violet’s love interests would be, Tobias was very much my least favorite. I liked him in the beginning of Thea’s story, but as her books progressed, I got to where I could hardly stand him. Wellll…this book completely changed my mind. I don’t know why I ever doubt Autumn because she never leaves me disappointed.
  • This book is suuuper slow-burn, which I both love and hate. When we finally get to see a *makin’ sweet love* scene, it’s so well worth the wait and I love everything about it…I just sort of wish we’d been able to see a full love scene with the other two guys (although, the sexy scenes they did get together were amazing, so don’t fret). This definitely didn’t ruin the story for me, it’s just something I always think of with RH novels like these. HOWEVER, what I read was beautifully written and I have no complaints. ❤


As is no surprise of an Autumn Reed novel, I loved this story. It was such a sweet romance while also showing how much strength Violet gains in the end. I highly recommend this book for anyone who’s a fan of reverse harem/college romance. And if you do end up reading, please come back and let me know what you thought!

Previous Reviews

The Lonely Souls Series: Spineless | Heartless | Witless
The Stardust Series: Polaris
The Collectors: Touch of Promise | Touch of Fate
Standalone: Scarlett, XO

Sign up for my newsletter!

Become a Patron!

Check out my Amazon storefront for several book lists, including a list of freebies!: Alated Bibliophile Storefront
Save this to your Pinterest boards!
alated bibliophile logo

You may also like...


  1. Romance genre isn’t really my kind of thing, nor is anything that’s slow burning, but you review was interesting nonetheless. However, I do have a question, what is a reverse harem?

    1. I appreciate that! My interests are super eclectic; I tend to jump around several different genres/subgenres.
      Haha, reverse harem involves a relationship between one woman and three or more men.

  2. I am also not a big fan of romance but I really like how you broke down your review of this book. I definitely am considering reading this.

    1. Thank you! That’s very appreciated <3

  3. Good review. Love the novels.

    1. thank you so much! I love them too 🙂

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.